The Spool / Reviews
The Good Daughter? Eh, just ok
Karin Slaughter’s adaptation of her own novel showcases excellent performances and little more.
NetworkPeacock,
6.3

One of pop culture’s longest-running questions is whether one aspect of a film or TV show can be so strong that it redeems the work as a whole. You can see it in defenses of the Avatar films, where its advocates argue that “film is a visual medium” and Avatar offers just so much visual. It is an argument I’ve mounted for The Negotiator regarding the acting elevating a fairly conventional script. Or, at least, I used to. Then, a certain actor revealed himself as deeply creepy, to put it mildly. In any case, the “answer”—so far as the question can be answered—is “Yes. To a point”. The Good Daughter, Karin Slaughter’s adaptation of her novel of the same name, nicely illustrates the second part of that answer. Meghann Fahy, Rose Byrne, and Brendan Gleeson headline a top-notch cast. And the series still disappoints.

Charlie (Fahy) and Sam (Byrne) are the adult children of defense attorney Rusty (Gleeson), a well-known figure in their town. He’s also widely despised for his insistence on tirelessly defending his clients, regardless of the charges they face. When they were children, Charlie and Sam survived a home invasion that their mother (Olivia Williams) did not. Sam, formerly a track star, suffered a traumatic brain injury. Physically, she mostly recovered, save some limited mobility and a stutter, especially when exhausted or during times of stress. Emotionally? That’s a very different answer. The estranged sisters are forced back together after Charlie survives a school shooting and Rusty is stabbed after taking on the apparent perpetrator, Kelly (Shayna Benardo), as a client.

The Good Daughter (<a href=Peacock) Brendan Gleeson" class="wp-image-57785"/>
Brendan Gleeson once again proves himself unafraid of fashion. Here he throws an absolute fit in hospital chic. (Mark Hill/Peacock)

It’s a hell of a hook, and the first episode casts a spell, ratcheting tension and laying breadcrumbs with equal skill. It also gives Pikeville, the small Georgia town where the girls grew up and where Charlie still lives, a real sense of place. Even better is how fully in command of her skills Fahy is here. After outshining several bigger names in The White Lotus Season 2 and snagging her first big cinematic role in the enjoyably tense, twisty Drop, she’s been stuck as the best thing in lesser series like Sirens and The Perfect Couple. In The Good Daughter pilot, she finally seemed to find another TV project that let her show her range and was worthy of it.

The second episode then reminds audiences that Byrne first broke through as a dramatic actor in Damages, even if her best work has been in comedies for the past decade or so. Playing a character with a stutter can be a real tightrope act. Too much and it feels like caricature. Too little and it seems like a distraction or, worse, a tool of convenience to show vulnerability. She calibrates it well, capturing how a stutter can rise and fall in reaction to stress and emotional and physical weariness. She plays Sam’s woundedness cleverly, mixing acid with vulnerability and making her an understandable but prickly protagonist.

The Good Daughter (<a href=Peacock) Harper Steele" class="wp-image-57787"/>
Poor Harper Steele. The only emotionally healthy person in the whole of Pikeville. (Daniel McFadden/Peacock)

Gleeson, Williams (in her limited screentime), Michael Dorman as Charlie’s estranged husband Ben, and Harper Steele as Rusty’s secretary and best friend all turn in top-notch work as well. Gleeson, especially, captures attention with a wonderfully human and slippery performance as the girls’ dad. He’s not a great dad. He’s too distracted by his work and his grief. But the actor locates a center that suggests, given different circumstances, Rusty could’ve been an ideal dad. It makes him a tremendously likable and frustrating figure. Paired with his work in Spider-Noir, it is a great reminder of his impressive versatility.

Sadly, the series stumbles after its initial two episodes. The actors remain strong, but Pikeville becomes increasingly indistinct, and several of its citizens feel a bit too broad and cartoony. The plot also becomes increasingly about everything—the school shooting, the decades-old home invasion, Charlie and Sam’s estrangement, Charlie’s crumbling marriage—blurring what started as a very clear-eyed show. There simply isn’t enough room for anything with so much going on, which repeatedly strands several potentially interesting aspects of the series or forces them to entirely too quick and clean resolution.

The Good Daughter (<a href=Peacock)" class="wp-image-57788"/>
Yes, Rose Byrne and Meghann Fahy are estranged. But don’t think they can’t still pull together a Mulder/Scully sibling cosplay at a moments notice. (Mark Hill/Peacock)

Ultimately, it resolves several mysteries in a way that the audience can only sit back and accept. There is a lack of satisfaction, as several episodes of sledgehammer-subtle foreshadowing precede some reveals while others arrive absolutely out of nowhere. Worse, even when the show makes it impossible to ignore the hints, it never fully explains the twist. It holds it to nearly the last moment and fails to explore any of its psychological aspects. Aspects that, given a chance, would have deep and resonant consequences for several characters.

So, yes, The Good Daughter boasts several good-to-excellent performances, especially from its two leads. And yet, ultimately, it is not enough. It finds that point and goes right past it.

The Good Daughter heads on down to Georgia Peacock on November 12.

The Good Daughter Trailer:

NetworkPeacock,