Read also:
How to Watch FX Live Without CableHow To Watch AMC Without CableHow to Watch ABC Without CableHow to Watch Paramount Network Without CableBehemoth! is a movie about orchestras, film scores, and cello playing. Yet, as a motion picture, it reminded me of a baseball scenario. So much talent assembled for this title from writer/director Tony Gilroy (who previously helmed Michael Clayton and showran Andor). The Behemoth! Collective responsible for the film’s music alone includes nine famous musicians and composers. Meanwhile, a bevy of gifted performers line up the cast. In other words, the bases are loaded for Behemoth!, there isn’t a cloud in the sky, a fantastic player is up on home plate. Yet a full home run remains elusive.
Behemoth! is not quite the equivalent of a “strike”. Some solid chops still materialized on this cinematic baseball diamond. However, wobbly bat handling and awkward base running turned a seemingly surefire victorious inning into something immensely frustrating.
All belabored baseball metaphors aside (I’m not a sports girl, sue me), Behemoth! follows cellist Alex Serian (Pedro Pascal), a childhood prodigy at his craft who’s grown into an aloof middle-aged man. Gilroy takes a cue from his 2009 film Duplicity (and even certain Andor episodes) in telling Serian’s story (which spans 2016 through 2026) non-linearly. Serian’s primary drama focuses on him returning to Los Angeles to care for his dying mom. Here, he and his podcaster brother Andy (Will Arnett) wistfully reminisce about existence’s pain and past regrets.

Meanwhile, Serian’s past keeps catching up with him. Sometimes, it’s through an ex-lover from Chicago, Carol Spedding (Olivia Wilde), who just won’t leave him alone. Other times, it’s performing his craft in recording studios like the one his grandfather allegedly passed away in. Boxes of his late father’s junk in a storage closet also keep bringing uncomfortable memories to the surface. Then there’s his fling with Nadia (Eva Victor), another masterful musician whose time with Serian ended poorly. Nadia’s shadow quietly looms over Behemoth’s lead character as he tries carving out a better present and future.
A go-to complaint for many movies is “that needed to lose 30 minutes.” Behemoth!, meanwhile, could’ve used an extra hour. In its current two-hour form, Gilroy’s script reduces crucial characters in Serian’s life to background players and leaves several emotional threads underfed. The production feels too much like a clip show rather than something substantive. A climactic montage aiming for (and failing to reach) “What’s Up, Danger” energy cuts across various figures and events from Serian’s past. As these images flicker on-screen, it just becomes more inescapable how minimal of an impression any of these elements have left.
Perhaps a more elongated runtime could’ve rendered characters like Serian’s mom (whose only seen twice on-screen) more impactful. Then again, a beefier length means soaking in even more of Gilroy’s tiresome Behemoth! dialogue. Everyone in this universe, no matter their age or mood, speaks like they’re in John Mulaney’s impersonation of the “next time on Mad Men” segments (“Shut the door!”).
All the verbiage gestures at weighty pontifications on regret and getting older. However, there’s too little specificity to make the words actually weighty. Everybody’s monologuing, but few have concrete personality traits or discernible humanity to exude. It all gets tiresome fast. Lord knows how three hours of this would be bearable.

These problems frustrate since the cast is game even with a deeply flawed script to work from. Pedro Pascal, for instance, is as compelling as ever, even if he seems slightly misdirected here. His puppy-dog face, combined with Gilroy’s direction to make Alex Serian so subdued and quiet, makes Pascal’s performance occasionally dissonant with how other characters talk about Alex.
People like Carol and Nadia say this guy’s a cad, a ladies’ man who never sticks around. Yet Pascal’s energy is largely affable and weary, not necessarily untrustworthy or restless. In other words, the Behemoth! characters say one thing about Alex while this Mandalorian veterans performance says something else. Even with this incongruity, Pascal delivers fine work, especially when he’s portraying Alex navigating his role as a mentor for young musician Bronte (Kaya Ralls). Their quiet scenes together are quite moving and demonstrate Pascal’s gift for delivering engaging acting in understated confines.
Gilroy and Damián García also generally imbue Behemoth! with solid visual instincts, particularly whenever they’re leaning into grandiosity. This quality dominates an early scene where Alex is outrunning Carol in a concert hall. Once the former characters goes outside, the bursts of snow falling to the ground look gorgeous. Ornately placed beams of light scattered throughout the environment are similarly radiant. Juxtaposing Alex’s frantic need to escape with such crisp camerawork and intricately staged images creates a mighty engaging set piece.
Gilroy’s stronger visual instincts also manifest in details reflecting which era Behemoth! suddenly occupies. Case in point: a background banner reading “CHICAGO” or a Hillary Clinton lawn sign. These time-conscious elements extend to Behemoth! unabashedly referencing uncomfortable recent historical events. Specifically, multiple mentions of COVID-19 upending lives both accentuate the authenticity of this world and poignantly speak to how external forces can upend our existence. Whether it’s a tormented upbringing or a global health crisis, greater forces often shape our worlds.

One eye-catching detail in Behemoth! is that Behemoth! Collective providing the score. Nine composers (including James Newton Howard, Alan Silvestri, Michael Giacchino, and Nami Melumad, among others) provide orchestral music for various Behemoth! sections. Between this and storytelling details like Serian playing cello for film scores across varying genres (a rom-com here, an action film there), Behemoth! provides plenty of auditory spectacle for one ticket price.
The score itself sounds solid, especially when it leans into maximalist emotions with its blaring horns or lively drumming. However, while generally well-crafted, the various Behemoth! tracks needed more individual personality. They’re solid at channeling familiar film score molds, but I yearned for more instrumentation flourishes or unique sounds that could belong to this movie. Perhaps the Behemoth Collective needed a greater array of types of musicians to really soar. Whatever the case, combining legends like Howard and Silvestri onto one soundtrack does yield some decent results.
Clearly, handsome craftsmanship and thoughtfulness aren’t absent in Behemoth! However, like a master clarinet performer stuck next to an off-tempo trumpet player, those better qualities exist alongside bafflingly generic creative choices. An avalanche of nebulous dialogue and underwritten women characters weigh things down. No matter how boisterous the score gets or Pedro Pascal cranks up his charms, Behomoth! remains too murky to get invested in.
Behemoth! opens in limited theatrical release on December 4th.