The Spool / Reviews
Disclaimer! This excellent drama comes with the price of deep unease
AppleTV+’s latest tells a dark, enthralling tale of the consequences of revenge run wild.
NetworkApple TV+
Similar23:23, A Boss and a Babe, A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms: The Hedge Knight, A Lifelong Journey, A Small Light, A Spy Among Friends, A Tale of Thousand Stars, A Touch of Frost A2Z, Adoration, Agatha Christie's Poirot Alba, All the Light We Cannot See, All the Same… or Not, Always a Witch Anatomy of a Scandal, Angel Flight, Anna Karenina Antiquarian Bookshop Biblia's Case Files, Anxious People, Apples Never Fall, Archangel, Arn: The Knight Templar, As Beautiful As You, Aspen, ASSASSINS PRIDE, Assistant of Superstar, Be My Favorite, Beacon 23, Bed Friend, Behind the Revenge, Bepannah, Between Us, Black Knight, Black Narcissus, Black Raven, Blank, Bleak House, Blinded by the Lights, Blossom, Blowing Kisses, Bocianie hniezdo, Bodies Boogiepop and Others Brahmarakshas, Brass Dreams, Bread and Soup and Cat Weather, Breaking Bad, Burnt Sugar, Business Proposal Café Minamdang, Cassandra, Catch-22 Chanpon Tabetaka, Chernobyl, City on Fire, Coffee Prince, Cooking Crush, Copycat Killer, Coroner, Corporate Office Lady Chie Maru Diary, Crescent Moon, Crossfire, Cupid's Command, Cute Bad Guy, DAHMER - Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story Darby and Joan, Darwin's Game, Dash & Lily, Dating in the Kitchen, Dear Doctor, I'm Coming for Soul, Dear Edward, Death and Nightingales, Death Comes to Pemberley, Deep Love Love Again, Deliver Me, Desire Zoo, Detective Forst, Dexter Dime Quién Soy: Mistress of War, Douluo Continent, Dr. Chocolate, Driven, Duty After School, Eagles and Youngster, East of Eden Echo, Eclipse of the Heart Elizabeth R, Emigration XD, Fatal Vision, Firefly Lane, First Kill, Fool Me Once Fosse/Verdon, Futari Monologue, Future, Game of Thrones Game Rak Patihan, Gangs of Galicia, GAP, Geek Girl, Genesis George & Tammy, Goodbye Earth, Gossip Girl Green Door, Griselda, Guardian, Harry Wild, Hart to Hart, Hello Anne: Before Green Gables, Hello, Me!, Hello, The Sharpshooter, High School Prodigies Have It Easy Even in Another World!, High School Return of a Gangster, Hold Tight, Hollywood, Hotel, Hymn of Death, Hysteria!, I Will Never Let You Go, If Tomorrow Comes, Informa, Inspector Morse, Irreplaceable Love, Island at War, Isn’t It a Ripoff?: The Job of a New Member of the Intellectual Property Department, Jane Eyre, Japan Sinks: 2020, Jekyll, Jesus, Jiu: Special Investigation Team, Kaleidoscope, Kamenskaya, Kamenskaya - 5, Kamenskaya - 6, Kane & Abel, Kidnapped, Kindred, Kindred: The Embraced, KinnPorsche: The Series, Kiseki: Dear to Me, Kiss that Kills: Parallel, Kogure Photo Studio, Kumokiri Nizaemon, Lakeside Murders, Land of Tanabata, Legend of the Galactic Heroes, Les Misérables, Lessons in Chemistry, Light My Way, Like a Flowing River, Logically Impossible! Detective Ryoko Kamizuru Is on the Case, Long For Fish, Lost in Baimu, Lost Ollie, Love By Chance, Love Is Sweet, Love Like the Galaxy, Love Syndrome III, Lovecraft Country, M*A*S*H Maid, Maneater, Manner of Death, Mare of Easttown, Marvellous Love, Master of the Game, Master of the House, Medical Examiner Dr. Qin: The Survivor Meet You at the Blossom, Meeting You Loving You, Melissa, Midnight Ferris Wheel, Midsummer Night, Millennium, MIOKA –MY LAST DAYS WITH YOU–, Monarch of the Glen MosGaz. Delo N1, MosGaz. Delo N2: Palach, Motto! Majime ni Fumajime Kaiketsu Zorori, Ms Ma, Nemesis, Murder Mindfully, Muted, My Beautiful Man, My Gear and Your Gown, My Marvellous Dream Is You, My Name, My Talented Husband, Nakhee's Necklace, Nazar, Nero Wolfe, Nine Perfect Strangers, No Escape NOS4A2, Nothing But You, Nutcracker: Money, Madness & Murder, O Tempo e o Vento, Obsession, Oh! My Sweet Liar!, Once and Forever: The Sun Rises, Open Book, Oranges Are Not the Only Fruit Outlander Pachinko, Palm Royale, Past Life, Present Love, Patria Pending Train, Perry Mason Place of Execution Planet of the Apes Poliana Moça, Pope John Paul II Presumed Innocent, Pretty Boy Detective Club, Pretty Little Liars: Original Sin, Pride and Prejudice Prisoner of Love, Provoke, Psych-Hunter Public Affairs Office in the Sky, Quatermass, Queen Cleopatra, Queer as Folk, Rak Nakara, Rascal Does Not Dream of Bunny Girl Senpai Raven of the Inner Palace, Reborn Rich, Rebus Recipe for Farewell, Recipes for Love and Murder, Reverse 4 You, Ring of Fire, Roswell, New Mexico, Run with the Wind, Saito-san, Scam 1992: The Harshad Mehta Story, Scully Scumbag System, Secret Crush On You, Seirei Gensouki: Spirit Chronicles, Senior High, Shadow and Bone, Shangri-La Shardlake, Sherlock Holmes Ski into Love, Sleeping Dog, Song of the Moon, Stolen Face, Sunny, Taken, Takin' Over the Asylum, Tales from the Neverending Story Teacup The 8 Show, The ABC Murders, The Act, The Agatha Christie Hour The Åre Murders, The Baxters, The Blood of Youth, The Bourne Identity The Calling, The Catch, The Consultant, The Crimson Rivers, The Curse, The Day of the Triffids, The Decameron, The Defence, The Demon Hunter's Romance, The Diary of Anne Frank The Eddy, The Edwardians, The Fall of the House of Usher, The Fear Index, The Fox's Summer The Frog, The Good Lord Bird, The Great Indian Murder, The Great Train Robbery, The Haunting of Bly Manor, The Helicopter Heist, The Hijacking of Flight 601, The Hunt for a Killer, The Ingenious One, The Inspector Lynley Mysteries The Irrational, The Jewel in the Crown, The Journalist, The Keepers, The Killer's Shopping List, The Kindergarten Detective, The Last Days of Ptolemy Grey, The Law Cafe, The Leftovers, The Legends of Changing Destiny, The Lies Within, The Life and Death of Ferdinand Luce, The Lincoln Lawyer, The Listeners, The Long Firm, The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power, The Lost World The Madness, The Magical Legend of the Leprechauns, The Magicians, The Mayor of Casterbridge, The Mess You Leave Behind, The Middleman's Love, The Midwich Cuckoos, The Minions of Midas, The Name of the Game is a Kidnapping, The Night Logan Woke Up, The Old Man, The Outsider The Palace, The Patients of Dr. García, The Penguin, The Perfect Couple The Plague, The Plot Against America, The Queen's Gambit, The Responder, The Rhinemann Exchange, The Savant, The Sealer, The Shield and the Sword, The Shining The Silence, The Singing Detective, The Sister, The Summer I Turned Pretty The Time Traveler's Wife, The Twilight Zone, The Tyrant, The Undoing The Whirlwind, The White Queen, The Word, The World of Fantasy, Those About to Die, Thousands of worlds, Three Women, Thriller, Through the Darkness Ties: A Miraculous Colt, Time and Him are Just Right, Tiny Pretty Things, Tokugawa Chronicles: Ambition of the 3 Branches, Touch Your Heart, Toward the Wilderness, Treason, Triple Fling, Tsurune, Ultimate Note, Ultraviolet, Unbelievable, Under the Microscope, Unknown, Until I Kill You, Vanity Fair, WandaVision, War & Peace, War Sailor, Wayward Pines WeCrashed, WHAT / IF, When We Were Young, White Teeth Who Is He, Who Were We Running From?, Why Didn't They Ask Evans?, Wild Palms, Without Breast There Is No Paradise, Women at War, World on a Wire, Would You Like to Play Da Capo?, Wycliffe YATAGARASU: The Raven Does Not Choose Its Master, Years and Years, Young Babylon, Your Sky, Youth, Yuri or Another, ZERO -The Bravest Money Game-, Каменская - 3,
Watch afterBlack Mirror Breaking Bad Fear the Walking Dead, Game of Thrones Good Omens, Loki Peaky Blinders Silo Squid Game Stranger Things Sugar, The Night Agent, The Penguin, The Simpsons
StudioApple Studios,
8.8
Disclaimer! This excellent drama comes with the price of deep unease

If you’ve seen or read enough stories about vengeance, chances are good you’ve encountered the saying, “He who seeks revenge digs two graves,” or some variation. Likely misattributed to Confucius, its meaning nonetheless carries weight. The new drama Disclaimer wrestles with the adage far more seriously than most other takes on the act of seeking catharsis through reprisal.

Teacher Stephen Brigstocke (Kevin Kline) has just finished self-destructively barreling into his own firing, quite the fall for a former Teacher of the Year. He’s alone, a widower, his wife Nancy (Lesley Manville) dead after a protracted time with cancer. However, in many ways, he’s been alone since their son Jonathan (Louis Partridge) died about two decades earlier. That’s when his wife began to pull away from him and didn’t stop until her death.

With his newfound time, he begins to clean out the closets and wardrobes left unused since her passing. Among the debris, he discovers a series of objects that lead to a manuscript. In its pages, Nancy lays out their son’s final days in Italy. More importantly, she places the blame for his death firmly at the feet of Catherine Ravenscroft (Cate Blanchett). Catherine is now a highly successful documentary filmmaker married to financier Robert (Sacha Baron Cohen) with an adult son, Nicholas (Kodi Smit-McPhee).

Disclaimer (AppleTV+) Kevin Kline
Like many of us, Kevin Kline can’t decides if it is to laugh or cry. (AppleTV+)

But back when Jonathan met her, Nancy’s book alleges, Catherine (Leila George in the flashbacks) was a young mom unhappy and alone with her young child (George Haarer). The manuscript goes on to suggest she and Jonathan had a brief but intensely sexual relationship, an allegation backed up by a stack of provocative photos taken with Jonathan’s camera. After their affair, Jonathan drowned, helping to save young Nicholas’s life.

With these revelations, the listless Stephen finds a new spark. He will, systematically, destroy Catherine with the book. She needs to pay for Jonathan’s death—and, by extension, the loss of Nancy. Stephen’s just the man to make it happen.

For much of the season, writer-director Alfonso Cuarón, adapting Renée Knight’s novel, plunges the viewers into this disturbing plan. They ride alongside Stephen as he enacts a campaign that’s a mix of harassment, embarrassment, isolation, and assault. While not a Funny Games in either tone or misanthropy, it forces the audience to ask similar questions of itself by the time the dust settles. Regardless of what Catherine might be guilty of, was Stephen’s plot a remotely equivalent response? How willing were the viewers to go along with it, and why? On its face, it is a vicious and cruel act, but it is Disclaimer’s seductive power that most won’t feel that until long after they should. And this critic does, sadly, include himself amongst that “they.”

Disclaimer (AppleTV+) Leila George
Leila George gets that good, good lighting. (AppleTV+)

Besides Cuarón’s hand, Kline’s performance deserves much credit for keeping viewers on his side even as the water climbs closer and closer to boiling. Going as grey, tired, and disheveled as he’s ever been on-screen, it is easy to see his Stephen as a pathetic figure. He fills his opening monologue about how little he cares about teaching now with hopeless resignation. He wanders about his empty home in his pajamas and his wife’s cardigan, buttoned around his notably larger frame. When he leaves the house, he wears it beneath his clothes and slathers on his son’s old cologne.

However, his increasingly hardened stare and venomous inner monologue give away the game. He’s a man “given” permission to act the monster. He starts driven but hesitant, unsure. In no time, though, he’s reveling in his “mission.” What he started as an obligation becomes a joy, and Kline lets us see every step.

Blanchett is equally good in what, in many ways, is the more challenging part. Besides being identified early as the series’ antagonist, she has to play things close to the vest and withdrawn. For the story to work, she can’t be too expressive—until she must. It’s easy to fade into the background playing such a part, but she lets the audience feel Catherine white-knuckling it. With every humiliation, every defeat, you can practically hear the teeth-grinding intensity keeping her in check.

Disclaimer (AppleTV+) Kodi Smit-McPhee Cate Blanchett Sacha Baron Cohen
Kodi Smit-McPhee, Cate Blanchett, and Sacha Baron Cohen enjoy another beautiful British day. (AppleTV+)

In contrast to Kline’s wolf in sheep’s clothing performance, Blanchett is visibly incandescent with her feelings, but she can’t speak them. They don’t even peek through in her part of the voiceovers. Putting them in the third person and having it recited by Indira Varma is a subtly smart choice. It distances the viewers that much further from Catherine’s secrets.

There are times when Disclaimer feels a bit unstructured and in need of a tighter edit. The line between slow build and just too slow is a thin one. However, when the series reaches its climax, it becomes harder to say if it’s gone on too long. Would that moment hit as hard if we hadn’t spent so long living, as it were, with Stephen? If we hadn’t seen Catherine’s trials and tribulations in as much detail? I’d argue it probably still runs a bit long, but it feels more justified when the full picture becomes clear.

Disclaimer is not an easy watch. It will likely make one feel queasy at times and perhaps even a little disgusted. If not at oneself, certainly at some of the characters. From a show-making and acting standpoint, though, it is worth the investment, as uncomfortable as it may be.

Disclaimer writes the book on revenge on AppleTV+ beginning on October 11.

Disclaimer Trailer:

NetworkApple TV+
Similar23:23, A Boss and a Babe, A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms: The Hedge Knight, A Lifelong Journey, A Small Light, A Spy Among Friends, A Tale of Thousand Stars, A Touch of Frost A2Z, Adoration, Agatha Christie's Poirot Alba, All the Light We Cannot See, All the Same… or Not, Always a Witch Anatomy of a Scandal, Angel Flight, Anna Karenina Antiquarian Bookshop Biblia's Case Files, Anxious People, Apples Never Fall, Archangel, Arn: The Knight Templar, As Beautiful As You, Aspen, ASSASSINS PRIDE, Assistant of Superstar, Be My Favorite, Beacon 23, Bed Friend, Behind the Revenge, Bepannah, Between Us, Black Knight, Black Narcissus, Black Raven, Blank, Bleak House, Blinded by the Lights, Blossom, Blowing Kisses, Bocianie hniezdo, Bodies Boogiepop and Others Brahmarakshas, Brass Dreams, Bread and Soup and Cat Weather, Breaking Bad, Burnt Sugar, Business Proposal Café Minamdang, Cassandra, Catch-22 Chanpon Tabetaka, Chernobyl, City on Fire, Coffee Prince, Cooking Crush, Copycat Killer, Coroner, Corporate Office Lady Chie Maru Diary, Crescent Moon, Crossfire, Cupid's Command, Cute Bad Guy, DAHMER - Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story Darby and Joan, Darwin's Game, Dash & Lily, Dating in the Kitchen, Dear Doctor, I'm Coming for Soul, Dear Edward, Death and Nightingales, Death Comes to Pemberley, Deep Love Love Again, Deliver Me, Desire Zoo, Detective Forst, Dexter Dime Quién Soy: Mistress of War, Douluo Continent, Dr. Chocolate, Driven, Duty After School, Eagles and Youngster, East of Eden Echo, Eclipse of the Heart Elizabeth R, Emigration XD, Fatal Vision, Firefly Lane, First Kill, Fool Me Once Fosse/Verdon, Futari Monologue, Future, Game of Thrones Game Rak Patihan, Gangs of Galicia, GAP, Geek Girl, Genesis George & Tammy, Goodbye Earth, Gossip Girl Green Door, Griselda, Guardian, Harry Wild, Hart to Hart, Hello Anne: Before Green Gables, Hello, Me!, Hello, The Sharpshooter, High School Prodigies Have It Easy Even in Another World!, High School Return of a Gangster, Hold Tight, Hollywood, Hotel, Hymn of Death, Hysteria!, I Will Never Let You Go, If Tomorrow Comes, Informa, Inspector Morse, Irreplaceable Love, Island at War, Isn’t It a Ripoff?: The Job of a New Member of the Intellectual Property Department, Jane Eyre, Japan Sinks: 2020, Jekyll, Jesus, Jiu: Special Investigation Team, Kaleidoscope, Kamenskaya, Kamenskaya - 5, Kamenskaya - 6, Kane & Abel, Kidnapped, Kindred, Kindred: The Embraced, KinnPorsche: The Series, Kiseki: Dear to Me, Kiss that Kills: Parallel, Kogure Photo Studio, Kumokiri Nizaemon, Lakeside Murders, Land of Tanabata, Legend of the Galactic Heroes, Les Misérables, Lessons in Chemistry, Light My Way, Like a Flowing River, Logically Impossible! Detective Ryoko Kamizuru Is on the Case, Long For Fish, Lost in Baimu, Lost Ollie, Love By Chance, Love Is Sweet, Love Like the Galaxy, Love Syndrome III, Lovecraft Country, M*A*S*H Maid, Maneater, Manner of Death, Mare of Easttown, Marvellous Love, Master of the Game, Master of the House, Medical Examiner Dr. Qin: The Survivor Meet You at the Blossom, Meeting You Loving You, Melissa, Midnight Ferris Wheel, Midsummer Night, Millennium, MIOKA –MY LAST DAYS WITH YOU–, Monarch of the Glen MosGaz. Delo N1, MosGaz. Delo N2: Palach, Motto! Majime ni Fumajime Kaiketsu Zorori, Ms Ma, Nemesis, Murder Mindfully, Muted, My Beautiful Man, My Gear and Your Gown, My Marvellous Dream Is You, My Name, My Talented Husband, Nakhee's Necklace, Nazar, Nero Wolfe, Nine Perfect Strangers, No Escape NOS4A2, Nothing But You, Nutcracker: Money, Madness & Murder, O Tempo e o Vento, Obsession, Oh! My Sweet Liar!, Once and Forever: The Sun Rises, Open Book, Oranges Are Not the Only Fruit Outlander Pachinko, Palm Royale, Past Life, Present Love, Patria Pending Train, Perry Mason Place of Execution Planet of the Apes Poliana Moça, Pope John Paul II Presumed Innocent, Pretty Boy Detective Club, Pretty Little Liars: Original Sin, Pride and Prejudice Prisoner of Love, Provoke, Psych-Hunter Public Affairs Office in the Sky, Quatermass, Queen Cleopatra, Queer as Folk, Rak Nakara, Rascal Does Not Dream of Bunny Girl Senpai Raven of the Inner Palace, Reborn Rich, Rebus Recipe for Farewell, Recipes for Love and Murder, Reverse 4 You, Ring of Fire, Roswell, New Mexico, Run with the Wind, Saito-san, Scam 1992: The Harshad Mehta Story, Scully Scumbag System, Secret Crush On You, Seirei Gensouki: Spirit Chronicles, Senior High, Shadow and Bone, Shangri-La Shardlake, Sherlock Holmes Ski into Love, Sleeping Dog, Song of the Moon, Stolen Face, Sunny, Taken, Takin' Over the Asylum, Tales from the Neverending Story Teacup The 8 Show, The ABC Murders, The Act, The Agatha Christie Hour The Åre Murders, The Baxters, The Blood of Youth, The Bourne Identity The Calling, The Catch, The Consultant, The Crimson Rivers, The Curse, The Day of the Triffids, The Decameron, The Defence, The Demon Hunter's Romance, The Diary of Anne Frank The Eddy, The Edwardians, The Fall of the House of Usher, The Fear Index, The Fox's Summer The Frog, The Good Lord Bird, The Great Indian Murder, The Great Train Robbery, The Haunting of Bly Manor, The Helicopter Heist, The Hijacking of Flight 601, The Hunt for a Killer, The Ingenious One, The Inspector Lynley Mysteries The Irrational, The Jewel in the Crown, The Journalist, The Keepers, The Killer's Shopping List, The Kindergarten Detective, The Last Days of Ptolemy Grey, The Law Cafe, The Leftovers, The Legends of Changing Destiny, The Lies Within, The Life and Death of Ferdinand Luce, The Lincoln Lawyer, The Listeners, The Long Firm, The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power, The Lost World The Madness, The Magical Legend of the Leprechauns, The Magicians, The Mayor of Casterbridge, The Mess You Leave Behind, The Middleman's Love, The Midwich Cuckoos, The Minions of Midas, The Name of the Game is a Kidnapping, The Night Logan Woke Up, The Old Man, The Outsider The Palace, The Patients of Dr. García, The Penguin, The Perfect Couple The Plague, The Plot Against America, The Queen's Gambit, The Responder, The Rhinemann Exchange, The Savant, The Sealer, The Shield and the Sword, The Shining The Silence, The Singing Detective, The Sister, The Summer I Turned Pretty The Time Traveler's Wife, The Twilight Zone, The Tyrant, The Undoing The Whirlwind, The White Queen, The Word, The World of Fantasy, Those About to Die, Thousands of worlds, Three Women, Thriller, Through the Darkness Ties: A Miraculous Colt, Time and Him are Just Right, Tiny Pretty Things, Tokugawa Chronicles: Ambition of the 3 Branches, Touch Your Heart, Toward the Wilderness, Treason, Triple Fling, Tsurune, Ultimate Note, Ultraviolet, Unbelievable, Under the Microscope, Unknown, Until I Kill You, Vanity Fair, WandaVision, War & Peace, War Sailor, Wayward Pines WeCrashed, WHAT / IF, When We Were Young, White Teeth Who Is He, Who Were We Running From?, Why Didn't They Ask Evans?, Wild Palms, Without Breast There Is No Paradise, Women at War, World on a Wire, Would You Like to Play Da Capo?, Wycliffe YATAGARASU: The Raven Does Not Choose Its Master, Years and Years, Young Babylon, Your Sky, Youth, Yuri or Another, ZERO -The Bravest Money Game-, Каменская - 3,
Watch afterBlack Mirror Breaking Bad Fear the Walking Dead, Game of Thrones Good Omens, Loki Peaky Blinders Silo Squid Game Stranger Things Sugar, The Night Agent, The Penguin, The Simpsons
StudioApple Studios,